Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Were Dusky Groupers Really This Big In Ancient Times
#1
[Image: duskygrouper.jpg]

If you look closely at this Roman mosaic you can see a large grouper swallowing a human man head first. That almost seems unbelievable, because groupers aren't found to be that large. But perhaps in the past they really were that size?

Quote:Modern groupers are known to reach about 3.5 feet long, and close to 5 feet is just possible under absolutely perfect circumstances, but this suggests they were once even bigger. Even adjusting for artistic licence, we're likely looking at a species that once enjoyed far more abundant food resources and, as a result, grew to generally greater lengths - enough to enter "sea monster" territory, at least as far as Roman mosaic-makers were concerned.

Secondly, the mosaics consistently depict people hunting the groupers with poles and harpoons. That fishing method wouldn't work out in the deep Mediterranean waters where the dusky grouper is now found. Instead, it strongly suggests that the grouper once lived in shallow waters, and in the intervening centuries has been forced out to the deep water. That fits with references made by the Roman authors Ovid and Pliny the Elder, both of who mention anglers fishing for groupers in shallow waters.

A new picture is potentially starting to emerge, thanks to these mosaics. Before the advent of more extreme commercial fishing practices, the groupers lived in the shallows, which provided them with far greater access to food. Consequently, they grew bigger and stronger than they do today. That's backed up by modern reserves, which have been built in shallow waters for the groupers and have since seen the fish grow up to 40 inches long, as opposed to 24 inches in more "natural" sites. It's all a remarkable example of how ancient art can become modern science.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
"Falsehood flies, and truth comes limping after it" - Jonathan Swift, 1710
Reply
#2
The Giant Grouper can grow up to 9 ft.

[Image: f031704t.jpg]
"Some of the best weapons do not shoot.”
U.S. Army Counterinsurgency Field Manual FM 3-24 December, 2006
BE PREPARED - http://www.gunsandall.com/

http://www.westerncivforum.com/index.php
Reply
#3
That's one big Oscar, isn't it?

habitat is important here. Is the giant grouper native to the Med, and is it a shallow water predator? The Dusky Grouper was a shallow water predator. The article talks about shallow spear fishing, so it had to inhabit shallow water.

And if they did, and grew huge, I can see where they would be dangerous to humans in ancient times, when ancient humans were closer to five feet in height. We forget that modern humans are much taller than the ancients.

Anyway, this is fascinating.


And this from Wikipedia, which perhaps explains why there are not all that many dusky groupers in the Med.

Quote:The Dusky Grouper (Epinephelus marginatus) is the best known grouper of the Mediterranean Sea and North Africa coast. It is said to have the best taste of all Mediterranean fishes.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
"Falsehood flies, and truth comes limping after it" - Jonathan Swift, 1710
Reply
#4
hmm, that one fish could feed a large family!
Quote: “A society that puts equality… ahead of freedom will end up with neither equality or freedom…a society that puts freedom first will, as a happy by-product, end up with both greater freedom and greater equality.” --Milton Friedman
relax. it's only the internet!
Reply
#5
It's interesting that the "Giant" grouper can be larger than the "Goliath" grouper.

Either could probably swallow at least what is shown in the image.
I know you think you understand what you thought I said,
but I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)